Now that the issues of fat adaptation and fat loss
versus ketosis—or the lack thereof—have been clarified, let’s move on to a
related issue that drives me crazy: newbie low-carbers freaking out if they eat
something that not only takes away that beloved purple, but—gasp!—causes the scale to go up a few
pounds.
When a low-carber who doesn’t understand some basics
about human physiology gains weight after indulging in a pile of something
sweet or starchy, they go absolutely apoplectic. Not knowing any better, they
step on the scale the next day, see that their weight has gone up a few pounds,
and they Just. Freak. Out. I can’t count how many times I’ve seen people post
to forums and message boards either in tears or in a raging anger, because they
ate a donut, or a bagel, or two slices of pizza, and gained, say, four pounds
the next day. They then fall into thinking that their body is so fundamentally
carbohydrate intolerant that after indulging in one carbohydrate-laden meal, they gained, overnight, four pounds of fat. (Never mind that the total weight of the amount of food they consumed for the entire day probably didn't even weigh four pounds, let alone that one bit of carb splurge, so I don't see any logic to how they think this works, but I digress.)
I’m not really sure how to talk about this without
expressing grave concern over these well-intentioned folks’ ignorance as to the
inner workings of their own bodies. (And by “expressing grave concern,” I mean,
“shaking my head at the utter lunacy out there.”)
Time for a quick lesson in glycogen storage.